Cigna vs Highmark Health for Employer Coverage | Best Review in 2025

Plan Offerings:

  • Open Access Plus (OAP): Nationwide network with no referral requirements, offering flexibility in choosing providers.
  • Preferred Provider Organization (PPO): Broad network access with out-of-network coverage options.
  • Health Maintenance Organization (HMO): Coordinated care through primary care physicians, focusing on preventive services.
  • LocalPlus®: Cost-effective plans with localized provider networks, suitable for employers seeking regional solutions.
  • SureFit® Plans: Customized networks designed in collaboration with local health systems to enhance care coordination.

Key Features:

  • Integrated Health Services: Comprehensive coverage encompassing medical, pharmacy, behavioral health, dental, and vision services.
  • Wellness Programs: Initiatives like lifestyle management coaching and health assessments to promote employee well-being.
  • Behavioral Health Support: Access to a nationwide network of mental health providers and resources.
  • Global Reach: Solutions for multinational businesses, including coverage for expatriates and international employees.

Employer Support:

  • Digital Tools: Employer portals for plan management and employee engagement analytics.
  • Cost Control Strategies: Programs aimed at reducing healthcare expenses through value-based care and preventive services.

Highmark Health: Employer Coverage Overview

Plan Offerings:

  • Small Group Plans: Tailored for businesses with 1-50 employees, offering essential health benefits.
  • Medium/Large Group Plans: Designed for organizations with 51 or more employees, providing comprehensive coverage options.
  • National Accounts: Solutions for companies with a nationwide presence, ensuring consistent benefits across locations.

Key Features:

  • Extensive Provider Network: Access to over 1.7 million providers and 95% of hospitals nationwide.
  • Behavioral Health Resources: Virtual mental health services and substance use disorder support programs.
  • Cost Savings Initiatives: Integrated solutions for pharmacy, spending accounts, and claims management to reduce overall expenses.
  • Digital Engagement: Mobile applications and online tools for members to manage their healthcare needs efficiently.

Employer Support:

  • Customized Onboarding: Personalized strategies to facilitate smooth transitions to new health plans.
  • Educational Resources: Materials and support to help employees understand and maximize their benefits.

Comparative Summary

FeatureCigna HealthcareHighmark Health
Plan VarietyOAP, PPO, HMO, LocalPlus®, SureFit®Small, Medium/Large, and National Group Plans
Provider NetworkNationwide with options for localized networksNationwide access to 1.7 million providers and 95% of hospitals
Behavioral Health ServicesComprehensive mental health and substance use supportVirtual mental health services and substance use disorder programs
Wellness ProgramsLifestyle management, health coaching, and preventive care initiativesPreventive care programs and wellness resources
Digital ToolsEmployer portals and employee engagement analyticsMobile apps and online tools for healthcare management
Global CoverageSolutions for multinational businesses and expatriatesPrimarily focused on U.S.-based coverage
Cost Management StrategiesValue-based care models and integrated health servicesIntegrated pharmacy and claims solutions to reduce costs

Final Considerations

  • Choose Cigna Healthcare if your organization:

    • Operates internationally and requires global health coverage.
    • Seeks a wide array of plan options with integrated health services.
    • Values comprehensive wellness and behavioral health programs.
  • Choose Highmark Health if your organization:

    • Is primarily U.S.-based and desires extensive national provider access.
    • Prioritizes digital engagement tools for employees.
    • Aims to implement cost-saving strategies through integrated solutions.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top