Horizon Blue Cross Medicare vs AmeriHealth Medicare | Best Review in 2025

Medicare Advantage plans offer an alternative way to receive your Medicare benefits, and choosing the right provider is crucial to ensure your healthcare needs are met. In New Jersey, Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield and AmeriHealth are two prominent providers offering Medicare Advantage plans. This article provides a detailed comparison of the Medicare plans from Horizon Blue Cross and AmeriHealth, focusing on their benefits, costs, and services to help you make an informed decision.

Overview of Medicare Advantage Plans

Medicare Advantage, also known as Medicare Part C, is an alternative to Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) and is offered by private insurance companies. These plans include all the benefits of Parts A and B and often provide additional benefits such as prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and wellness programs.

Horizon Blue Cross Medicare Advantage Plans

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey is one of the state’s largest health insurers and offers a range of Medicare Advantage plans tailored to meet different healthcare needs and budgets.

Plan Options and Features

  • Horizon Medicare Blue Advantage (HMO): This plan offers a $0 monthly premium option with in-network coverage, preventive services at no extra cost, and includes prescription drug coverage. Members must use plan providers except in emergencies.
  • Horizon Medicare Blue Select (HMO-POS): Allows more flexibility than traditional HMO plans by offering out-of-network coverage at a higher cost. This plan also includes enhanced dental benefits and lower prescription drug copays.
  • Horizon Medicare Blue Value (HMO): Focuses on members who seek lower-cost healthcare options. It has low or no premiums and includes basic dental and vision coverage.

Additional Benefits

  • Wellness Programs: Access to SilverSneakers, a popular fitness program for seniors.
  • Care Management Programs: Specialized support for chronic conditions such as diabetes and heart disease.
  • Telemedicine Services: Free or low-cost access to health professionals via phone or video.

AmeriHealth Medicare Advantage Plans

AmeriHealth New Jersey offers a range of Medicare Advantage plans that emphasize flexibility and member wellness.

Plan Options and Features

  • AmeriHealth Advantage (HMO): This plan typically offers $0 premiums and includes comprehensive medical and prescription drug coverage. Requires use of network providers for the lowest costs.
  • AmeriHealth Premier (PPO): A more flexible plan that allows members to see providers outside the network at a higher cost. This plan is ideal for those who may spend time in multiple states.
  • AmeriHealth Advantage Rx (HMO): Focuses on individuals who need extensive prescription drug coverage. Includes additional benefits like routine vision and hearing care.

Additional Benefits

  • Fitness Benefits: Free membership to fitness centers and access to wellness programs tailored to senior health.
  • Nurse Line: 24/7 access to a nurse hotline for immediate health queries.
  • Preventive Services: Includes a wide range of preventive services at no additional cost to the member.

Cost Comparison

When comparing Horizon and AmeriHealth, consider not only the premium but also the out-of-pocket costs such as copays, coinsurance, and deductibles. Both insurers offer plans with $0 premiums, but the costs for services and drugs can vary significantly.

Service Area and Network

  • Horizon Blue Cross: Has an extensive network across New Jersey, which is beneficial if you require access to a variety of specialists.
  • AmeriHealth: While also comprehensive, the network is slightly more limited compared to Horizon. However, the PPO plan offers good out-of-state coverage.

Customer Service and Ease of Use

Both companies have strong customer service ratings, but it’s important to read current member reviews and possibly contact customer service with any specific questions to gauge responsiveness and helpfulness.

Choosing between Horizon Blue Cross and AmeriHealth for Medicare Advantage depends on your specific health needs, budget, and preferred type of coverage. Both offer robust plans with competitive benefits, but the right choice will depend on your personal preference for plan structure (HMO vs. PPO), budget considerations, and the importance of having a broad provider network. It’s advisable to review each plan’s details during the Medicare open enrollment period and consider consulting with a Medicare advisor to help make the best choice for your healthcare needs.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top